Point of View
I was on that patrol. So it is with some justification that you will think it is autobiographical. You will be especially led to this because it is called a
Memorial, and appears to make appeals to official and definitive
documentation. However, don't be too misled. The same things afflict me
that agonize most writers. We tend to see the whole world, as is repeated
from Submarine Worlds, in a grain of sand, let alone a submarine which
literally cries out for the analogy--planetized off in the deeps like it is from
the rest of creation--with its tribes and its provinces and each submarine's
own individual Weltanschauung.
Persons.
It is even worse in the case of persons. And here I address myself most
intensely and with particular emphasis to my fellow submariners: No single real person is
intended to any substantial detail in this history, with the exception of myself, Edwin
Arnold (I use my middle name out of pure orneriness as is the inalienable right of every
submariner) Kiefer, and the Trout's Captain, "Mike" Fenno. And, of course, the
questions, devotion and raw courage of the strategically abandoned defenders of
Corregidor.
The rest are made up and tortured out of all verisimilitude to anyone
on the Trout, or to any other person-past or present. In this, it's not enough that I've
cocktail-shakered so many different persons together, and poured them at will into
whatever role was needed to illustrate the large and small significances of their and our
patrol, the now has also been unceremoniously transposed into their and our past and
mid-past to show continuity and development of themes.
So beware of pointing to this or that fictional character and saying, "I
know who that is! He's old so-and-so." Oh, to be sure, an old familiar gleam will
shoot forth into our consciousness from time to time. But, almost without exception, you
will be looking at jigsaw, made-up persons, constructs made to put art in a short compass
and humanity into a mere handful of finite human vessels to serve the purposes of love and
remembering.
Places and Circumstances.
The Submarine Trout, on one of its very first patrols, was
determining how one goes about fighting a submarine war.
They're all cut pure from life.
|
This book is about submarines, mostly about the unusualness of them, and the
things about what the pilgrimages into secular glory experienced in them surprised in
ourselves. Not that this is a circumstance peculiar to experienced glory in submarines in
World War II; but, rather, perhaps, it will represent due to its compressed and graphic
detail, a kind of parable that may encourage and inform others in their individual
pilgrimages.
Point of View
I was a participant in most of the
submarines that form the backgrounds of the novel, The Anatomy of Glory, as well as some
of the other narratives and tales included. So it is with some justification that you will
think it is autobiographical. You will be especially led to this because of its air of
familiarity and specificity of detail. And to a great extent this would be
well-founded.
I, after all, am not writing about events cribbed from a "borrowed" experience
like Melville in Moby Dick. I was there! I didn't project myself into the
"story." I, myself, was in the "whale's belly." I experienced the
events written about.
There are graphs, reconstructions, technical detail,
diagrams, confessions, poems, pictures
and much much more.
However, don't be too misled. The same things afflict me that agonize most
writers. We tend to see the whole world in a grain of sand, let alone in a submarine that
virtually cries out for the analogy planetized off in the deeps like it is from the rest
of creation--with its tribes and its provinces, and each submarine's own individual Weltanschauung.
Persons.
It is even worse in the case of persons. And here I address myself most
intensely and with particular emphasis to my fellow submariners: No single actual person
is intended in any substantial detail in this history, with the exception of those whose
real names are used. The rest are all made up and tortured out of all verisimilitude to
anyone on any of the magnificent submarines into which you are about to enter, hopefully,
into an intensely felt vicarious adventure of the heart and soul or to any other person,
past or present.
Exampled here is the interesting personification of history precedent in
Aristotle's careful treatment of the anatomically facilitated behavior of the dolphin that may well have motivated his student Alexander's
successful and innovative investment of the formerly impregnable city of
Tyre.
In this, it's not enough that I've gathered so many different persons
together, and poured them at will into whatever role was needed to illustrate the large
and small significances of their and our patrols, the now has also been unceremoniously
transposed into their and our past and mid-past to show continuity and development of
themes. So beware of pointing to this or that fictional character and saying, "I know
who that is! He's old so-and-so. " Oh, to be sure, an old
submariner or fellow-traveler will thrust himself forward from time to time. Almost without exception, and those
narrowly indicated by the use of their real names, you will be looking at
created constructs, made to put art in a short compass and humanity into a mere
handful of finite human vessels to serve the purposes of love and remembering.
Places and Circumstances
They're all cut pure from life or reported from
the careful considerations of an ardent heart and
searching mind
|
| The main reason for this
major workof 467 pages is to examine the distinguishing characteristics of submarine
technology and crews; and, the chief thrust here is to characterize the interwoven nature
of spirit and machine that wrought the phenomenon of underwater warfare in World War II.
Incorporating much of what has appeared in my former publications, PILGRIM FISH finds,
here, an interpretive wholeness.
PILGRIM FISH also develops the proto-typical evidences of these things from
earliest times in the section called, THE WHITE AND THE BLUE OF IT. It seemed apt to
figure the double-sourced gift giver of Upper and Lower Egypt in this way, and to make of
them the start of an objective correlative associated with the three parts of the book.
THE WHITE AND THE BLUE OF IT becomes a combined flow into a mainstream of
matured and successful American submarine design and personnel and is called THE NILE OF
IT.
This long and carefully developed section roots the bringing together of the sea
and submarines in an American youth's pilgrimage through the extraordinary events of the
California of the fall of 1941.
The section concludes with the same youth, now an apprentice seaman, on his way
to Corregidor on the storied Gold Patrol of the USS Trout. It is only a few weeks after
the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor had abruptly interrupted and thus unceremoniously
terminated his training at San Diego Boot Camp. The actual and
carefully developed events that transpire on this patrol make pro forma accounts of the
behavior of an American submarine crew on patrol appear to have happened in a different
world and in a different submarine force. Discovered here is an anatomy of glory itself,
and the metaphysics and muscle of a submarine pure.
THE DELTA OF IT section concludes the book with the working out of the
experiential metaphysics and muscle of selected submarines of America and the other
nations of the West as they stream out in their different but closely associated courses
to the general sea of war. The means by which the book approaches its thematic objectives
here is not by point and tell, but by nurturing an objective development from internally
generated and true story values outward.
The submarine experience, throughout its universal involvement in World War II,
urges its true definition in this work, but that is not the sole or even primary reason.
One does not have to be a specialist to appreciate the sense of mystique with which the
very idea of the submarine is invested. It compels closer examination by layman and
specialist alike.
The heated expression of war, while more clearly and frequently delivering the
main lineaments of this mystique, does not by this continuing frequency appear to lessen,
but only to heighten the general fascination with submarines and things submarine. The
reasons for this lie everywhere around us.
In many ways the submarine is the pre-eminent sign for our time, as Dagon-Jonah
was for that generation of long ago. It is as though there are keys to ourselves and
portents of the future here that are still needful of being found. Even experienced
submarine veterans have an untiring hunger for peering more closely back into the
imponderables of the defining moments they experienced in wartime's Silent Service. But
the real, been-there submarine veterans do so only privately; and, even here, the raw
stuff and verities of matters submarine are too often only shared by the knowing wink, the
quick, eloquent, and arcane allusion, and the myriad other individually communitied,
submarine by submarine, referents.
Pilgrim Fish Rosetta Stone's this lingua franca of the submarine community and
leads the reader, no matter his nationality, background, position or profession, to read
better into his own submarine associations in this world The development of a technology
produces a record; and the actual experience of man in association with that technology
produces some kind of history. The technological records of submarines as well as the
historical context within which that development took place are generously available to
the diligent researcher. This is particularly true for the submarine experience in the
United States where submarines have been notably present at critical junctures of her
military history: The Revolutionary War, the Civil War, and World Wars I and II.
Within world submarine history generally, the same situation obtains. There is
the exploitation of Aristotle's analysis of the diving apparatus of the dolphin arguably
motivating Alexander the Great's first underwater descent. There is Van Drebbel and his
first submarine taxi service across the Thames. Extensive information exists about that
American Renaissance man, Robert Fulton, making a detailed submarine building proposal to
the French Directory, and finally to Napoleon himself. The proliferation of stories about
the submarine experiences of other nations, particularly Germany, are also plentifully
available.
There appears, on the surface, to be no dearth of literature in all three of
these categories. However, the rich vein of another value, and one that is at least as
important a resource in the matter, the submarine spirit, has been never or only
indifferently tapped.The reasons for this state of affairs in the American submarine
effort are not hard to find. Patrol reports are, by their very nature, attack or mission
intensive accounts. They are, within certain broad constraints, career supportive briefs
prepared by submarine captains or their designees. This is an environment not very well
suited for the kind of effort that was possible for a Jean de Joinville or a Geoffroy
Villehardouin writing on the Crusades.
The organization of any identifiable system of human enterprise has a
metaphysical structure, a corporate consciousness, a shared and participative being of
place, time and historical precedents. This metaphysical thread, as a kind of helix, winds
inseparably about the submarine-extended psyche of the crew.
But a submarine crew is a close-mouthed lot. The American Silent Service of
World War II, unremittingly conditioned to ever greater degrees of secrecy, has been even
further taught by the changing norms of our culture to equate military glory with the same
reprehensibility that used to be reserved for pornography. This is silence layered on
silence; and, not the easiest thing in the world to overcome. I have worked with this
obdurate attitude during seven years of publishing the quarterly Submarine Journal magazine
with the special advantage of being a fellow submariner. Similarly, my war-long submarine
experience has provided some measure of discernment in reading evasions, interpreting
coded references, and anticipating the subtleties of relationships. One of the saddest
things of my postwar experiences is to see furtiveness and uncertainty standing as a
barrier between the surface of their stories, and the true submarine values that are to be
found beneath them.
The reticence in Germany is doubled again from that to be found in The United
States. However, my regular attendance and story-collecting at the annual international
conclaves of the International Submarine Association has tended to overcome these
understandable barriers. The French, however, have no such inhibitions; nor, for that
matter do the Italians. A former French crew member, for a season, on the controversial
Surcouf was quite candid about the circumstances to be found aboard her. The English are
exuberantly forward in their participation, although, even here, they recently decided to
jettison the official black tie of their organization famed for sporting the Jolly Roger.
The spirit of a submarine can darken and grow sour. The supportive exoskeleton of the
submarine can wrong its intent, and be critically less than it could be. Metaphysics, like
poetry, has a soft and vulnerable underbelly of the potential loss of the willing
suspension of unbelief. The incremental reduction of hardware effectiveness is usually
found coupled to such a darkening crew spirit. The book does not shrink from the careful
examination of such things and the events and submarines with which they may be
associated. The sensible value of discernible truth is the sine qua non of any book such
as this where its acquisition should be accounted of an importance equal to its
entertainment or aesthetic worth.
Finally, I can find no better way to conclude with a statement of the values I
hope this book provides than the one provided by that old sea-struck poet, Homer:
For none has ever driven by this way in his black ship, till he
hath heard from our lips the voice sweet as the honeycomb, and had joy thereof and gone
his way the wiser.
|